|
|
Post by TheDavii on Aug 29, 2008 6:26:09 GMT -5
|
|
|
|
Post by TheDavii on Sept 3, 2008 20:49:13 GMT -5
Helloooo.... guys, are you paying attention to this thread any more? Read the above, we need more links posted.
|
|
|
|
Post by OMFGitsVico on Sept 4, 2008 12:38:22 GMT -5
How many more cards do we need?
|
|
|
|
Post by fifisdead on Sept 4, 2008 12:56:13 GMT -5
I think we were trying to get at least all of the cards of the top 5 contributors, at least Davii said that somewhere...
So I think we're waiting on Moosh and Samu?...
also Davii, you left out my version of unnatural selection...and I uploaded a version of the Stick with the proper text and modified my post to include the proper url...
I also noticed that all of yours and some of Vico's have a white border whereas none of mine do... I'm not sure how you added that, but it's not on my Template...
and do you want us to put the carrot logo on all of our cards?...I noticed you hadn't done that yet...
|
|
|
|
Post by TheDavii on Sept 4, 2008 14:11:45 GMT -5
I think we were trying to get at least all of the cards of the top 5 contributors, at least Davii said that somewhere... So I think we're waiting on Moosh and Samu?... Moosh isn't in the top 5, but Samu is. Moosh hasn't submitted any fan art, as far as I know. also Davii, you left out my version of unnatural selection...and I uploaded a version of the Stick with the proper text and modified my post to include the proper url... I'll fix it. I was in a hurry to get more posted and skipped it 'cause I thought it was the same card. I also noticed that all of yours and some of Vico's have a white border whereas none of mine do... I'm not sure how you added that, but it's not on my Template... Any images are as they are present in the files. I didn't do anything other than link to them. and do you want us to put the carrot logo on all of our cards?...I noticed you hadn't done that yet... I haven't posted my suggestions for "ground rules" yet. Mine build on vico's scoring categories. One of them is that the decal should not be affixed to a card unless it is selected as one of the 16 final cards. |
|
|
|
Post by fifisdead on Sept 4, 2008 14:37:15 GMT -5
Any images are as they are present in the files. I didn't do anything other than link to them.
ok...what I was asking was how do yours have a white border, on your originals...My template that I got from KillerBunnies.com does not have such a border...
|
|
|
|
Post by TheDavii on Sept 4, 2008 14:41:05 GMT -5
Any images are as they are present in the files. I didn't do anything other than link to them. ok...what I was asking was how do yours have a white border, on your originals...My template that I got from KillerBunnies.com does not have such a border... D'oh. I created my own template since I wanted a vector template, so I added a back-most-element that is a rounded rectangle with a 0.25pt black line as the stroke. The fill is either white or black (for Omega/Psi). While we're at it, how much more work would it be for a link to cards' "Bunny Bits" (or MC.com forum post where they were introduced)? If one (or both) of you can post links to mjibber's individual card images, I can handle the other artists' links, as I have the card names and I'll search for the posts. These are my proposals for Ground Rules and Rating System (which is only slightly modified from Vico's idea): Ground Rules: Updated 9 Sept 2008- Card ideas for which "fan art" has been created are eligible because the point is to have something to put on a Bunny Blank.
- Text-only card ideas are ineligible.
- They must be posted on the Internet for general public availability (i.e., they can be linked to and are not limited to MC.com postings).
- Cards do not need to be complete and finished (although they will suffer in the scoring without being complete).
- Cards must be in their individual graphic files. Two or more graphic images per link disqualifies an entry.
- All scoring will be held in "public" view, though the individual dimension scores may not be available due to the difficulty of posting multi-dimensional data in a two-dimensional table.
- Scoring is on a [1..5] scale, inclusive. Single decimals may be used (e.g., 2.7, 3.3, 5.0), but numbers will be rounded off to one decimal place.
- Anyone with a registered account on MC.com may volunteer to be a judge.
- Comments should be submitted by 30 September 2008, but may be submitted through 31 October 2008.
- Cards must be posted and submitted by 31 October 2008 to be eligible (including any revisions based on comments posted).
- Cards will be sorted alphabetically by Card Title, so that multiple submissions of the same idea are adjacent and can be directly compared.
- Judges must review, score, and submit scores for all cards by 31 December 2008 or their evaluations will be ignored (i.e., a judge may not review a subset of the entries).
- Judges must review their own cards, but are expected to be fair.
- Each category is weighted equally (10%)
- The top 16 cards, by their scores, will be anointed the "2009 Official Magic Carrot Card Set". (Future sets, if any, will have a different designator.)
- Submissions may not have the "Official Magic Carrot Card Set decal" affixed to them prior to 31 October 2008 (to prevent bias by the judges). Existing decals should be removed [e.g., the decal on "The End Is Nigh" should be removed].
- Artists may request that their entries be removed from the judging.
- Previous "Official Magic Carrot Card Set" winning entries (the cards) are not eligible for future contests.
| Dimension | Description | Notes | | Quality of art | Is the artwork clean and precise? | Artwork that has clean lines, solid fills, anti-alias edges, and a clean appearance should be rated highly. Artwork that has ragged lines, messy fills, jagged edges and a messy appearance should be rated low. | | Official card appearance | Does the artwork look similar to the artwork by JB and JY? | "Indistinguishable from CTA" should be rated highly and "barely recognizable by a KB fan" being rated low. | | Quality of card rule | Does the rule make sense? Is the card free of any loopholes? Is the nomenclature consistent with the official cards? Is the grammar correct? | Cards that have quality rules (clear, no loopholes or omissions) should be rated highly. Cards that do not have quality rules should be rated low. Cards with grammar and spelling errors should be downrated. | | Originality of card rule | Does the card mechanic offer anything new? | Cards that have originality of the card mechanism should be rated highly. Cards that are derivative in their play should be rated low. Bunny Bits should offer clarification, not embody the rule. Similar ideas without art should not count against submissions. | | Playability | Is the card useful? Is it practical to use in a game? | Cards that would be useful additions to the realm of Magic Carrot and KB fans should be rated highly. Cards that are not useful (when used in practice, or when the opportunities for use are rare) should be rated low. | | Balance | Is the card too powerful? Is the card too weak? | Cards with "outstanding balance" rate a 5, while cards with "poor balance" (both too powerful and too weak) rate a 1. A card that balances an existing unbalanced card (for which there is no CTA countermeasure) should be rated highly. | | Quality of title | Does the card title make sense? Does it correlate with the card's purpose? | Card titles that make sense, once the cultural reference, pun, or word play is understood and that correlates with the card's purpose, should be rated highly. Card titles that do not make sense, once the cultural reference, pun, or word play is understood, nor correlate with the card's purpose should be rated low. | | Originality of title | Is the card title original and clever? Is it obvious/derivative? | Card Titles with clever word play, puns, and oblique cultural references should be rated highly. Card Titles that are merely descriptive (e.g., "Free Water" describing a card to acquire water without Dolla cost) should be rated low. | | Complexity | Is the card confusing? Is it too complicated? | Confusing or complicated should be scored low, while straight-forward ideas should be scored high. | | Overall approval | How well do you like this card? | Cards with which you would like to play should be rated highly. Cards with which you would not like to play should be rated low. |
|
|
|
|
Post by fifisdead on Sept 4, 2008 16:41:32 GMT -5
what do you mean by "previous "Official Magic Carrot Card Set" winners are not eligible for future contests."?
and what about a period for suggestions to be made to cards? Like if something is funky with the art or the wording could be made a little more clear?...
|
|
|
|
Post by TheDavii on Sept 4, 2008 17:13:21 GMT -5
I meant that the cards that "win" the 2009 contest cannot compete in any future contests, so any future card sets will contain unique cards and not dupes. In re-reading it, it was unclear. My apologies. [Update: I have changed the wording.]
We can certainly add a period for commentary too. Suggestion(s)? That might take it right up to the end of the year, though.
[Update: Changed year from 2008 to 2009.]
|
|
|
|
Post by TheDavii on Sept 4, 2008 17:39:55 GMT -5
Sorry for the double-post, but yes, exactly like that. Part 2 of 3 of the table, because it no longer fits in two posts: Updated 24 October 2008 6:24 am CDT | Card Number | Supertitle | Title | Subtitle | Thumbnail | Bunny Bits | Artist | Kind | Type | | 101 | | Digitize! | |  | Bunny Bits | Todd | Special | Special | | 102 | | Dirty Nappy Stench | Weapon Level 06 |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Weapon | Run | | 103 | | Dizzy Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | baylorgirl | | Play Immediately! | | 104 | | Don't Sink My Battleship | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Very Special | Very Special | | 105 | | Don't Sink My Battleship | |  | Bunny Bits | omfgitsvico | Run | Run | | 106 | | Donnelaith Cookbook | |  | Bunny Bits | Tyberius | Very Special | Very Special | | 107 | | Double Agent | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Special | Special | | 108 | | Double Dog Dare | | | Bunny Bits | Tyberius | Run | Run | | 109 | | Double Double Vision | |  | | FIFisDead | Run | Run | | 110 | | Downgrade | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Run | Run | | 111 | | Downpour | |  | Bunny Bits | samu | Special | Special | | 112 | | Dust Bunnies | |  | Bunny Bits | Watergazer | Run | Run | | 113 | | Easter Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | trebor1782 | Bunny | Special | | 114 | | Easter Confection | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Terrible Misfortune | Play Immediately! | | 115 | | Elm-Hare's Glue-All | |  | Bunny Bits | battlehawk77 | Special | Special | | 116 | | The End Is Nigh | |  | Bunny Bits | omfgitsvico | Run | Run | | 117 | | Energizer Bunny | |  | | FIFisDead | Roaming Red Run | Run | | 118 | | Enormous Prune Danish | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Very Special | Very Special | | 119 | | Fat Bunny Sings | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Very Special | Very Special | | 120 | | Fat Bunny Sings | |  | Bunny Bits | Watergazer | Very Special | Very Special | | 121 | It Ain't Over Until The | Fat Bunny Sings | |  | Bunny Bits | TheDavii | Very Special | Very Special | | 122 | | It Ain't Over | (Until The Fat Bunny Sings) |  | Bunny Bits | HaresonFord | Very Special | Very Special | | 123 | | Feed Me | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Special | Special | | 124 | | Ferret Funfair | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Run | Run | | 125 | | Fireproof | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Run | Run | | 126 | | Flo's Secret Recipe | |  | Bunny Bits | omfgitsvico | Run | Run | | 127 | | Flying Attack Monkey | Weapon Level 12 |  | Bunny Bits | StephenK | Roaming Red Run | Run | | 128 | | Force Field | |  | Bunny Bits | squidtaco | Very Special | Very Special | | 129 | | Fort Knox | |  | Bunny Bits | samu | Special | Special | | 130 | | The Four Seasons | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Special | Special | | 131 | | Frank The Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | omfgitsvico | Bunny | Run | | 132 | | Frankenbunny | |  | Bunny Bits | Watergazer | Run | Run | | 133 | | Free Parking | |  | Bunny Bits | omfgitsvico | Run | Run | | 134 | | Free Parking | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Run | Run | | 135 | | Full Speedo Ahead! | |  | | FIFisDead | Run | Run | | 136 | | Full Speedo Ahead! | |  | Bunny Bits | StephenK | Special | Special | | 137 | | Funny Bunny Munny | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Very Special | Very Special | | 138 | | General Consensus | |  | Bunny Bits | omfgitsvico | Run | Run | | 139 | | Gift Certificate B | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Special | Special | | 140 | | Girl Baby Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Run | Run | | 141 | | Girl Baby Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Run | Run | | 142 | | Girl Baby Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Run | Run | | 143 | | Go Donner | |  | Bunny Bits | samu | Run | Run | | 144 | | Go To Jail | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Run | Run | | 145 | | Golden Congenial | |  | Bunny Bits | a6cavey | Run | Run | | 146 | | Golden Gleeful | |  | Bunny Bits | a6cavey | Run | Run | | 147 | | Golden Lumbering | |  | Bunny Bits | a6cavey | Run | Run | | 148 | | Golden Sinister | |  | Bunny Bits | a6cavey | Run | Run | | 149 | | Golden Timid | |  | Bunny Bits | a6cavey | Run | Run | | 150 | | Good Karma | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Run | Run | | 151 | | Gus's Mirror Universe | |  | Bunny Bits | omfgitsvico | Run | Run | | 152 | | Celebrity Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | TheDavii | Bunny | Run | | 153 | | Half-Pink, Half-Black Congenial Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | TheDavii | Bunny | Run | | 154 | | Half-Pink, Half-Black Gleeful Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | TheDavii | Bunny | Run | | 155 | | Half-Pink, Half-Black Lumbering Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | TheDavii | Bunny | Run | | 156 | | Half-Pink, Half-Black Sinister Bunny | (Weapon Level 1) |  | Bunny Bits | TheDavii | Bunny | Run | | 157 | | Half-Pink, Half-Black Timid Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | TheDavii | Bunny | Run | | 158 | | Happy Cthulhu | |  | Bunny Bits | samu | Incredible Fortune | Play Immediately! | | 159 | | Hare Removal | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Run | Run | | 160 | | Hare-atio Caine | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Run | Run | | 161 | | Hare-ell Owens | |  | Bunny Bits | dedrabbit42 | Bunny | Run | | 162 | | Hare-Loss Treatment | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Very Special | Very Special | | 163 | | Hareburglar | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Run | Run | | 164 | | Hi Coups | |  | Bunny Bits | trebor1782 | Special | Special | | 165 | | Hikaru's Katana | |  | Bunny Bits | omfgitsvico | Run | Run | | 166 | | Holy Hand Grenade Of Antioch | |  | Bunny Bits | trebor1782 | Run | Run | | 167 | | Honey Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Special | Special | | 168 | | Hop-Zilla | |  | Bunny Bits | dedrabbit42 | Roaming Red Run | Run | | 169 | | Hundreth Monkey Theory | |  | Bunny Bits | Jeffro | Run | Run | | 170 | | Hungry Coyote | |  | Bunny Bits | Watergazer | Run | Run | | 171 | | The Hutch | |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Run | Run | | 172 | | Hybrid Energy | |  | Bunny Bits | glasscrosses | Very Special | Very Special | | 173 | | I ♥ Huckabunnies | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Very Special | Very Special | | 174 | | Improbability Drive | |  | Bunny Bits | battlehawk77 | Very Special | Very Special | | 175 | | It's A Mad, Mad World | |  | Bunny Bits | omfgitsvico | Special | Special | | 176 | | Jackalope Antlers | |  | Bunny Bits | Watergazer | Run | Run | | 177 | | Jay & Silent Bunny Strike Back | (Tourette's Syndrome) |  | Bunny Bits | TheDavii | Special | Special | | 178 | | Celebrity Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | TheDavii | Bunny | Run | | 179 | | Juiced | |  | Bunny Bits | FIFisDead | Run | Run | | 180 | | Jumping Jackalope | |  | Bunny Bits | Watergazer | Run | Run | | 181 | | Kamikazi | |  | | FIFisDead | Special | Special | | 182 | | King Of Hop | |  | Bunny Bits | dedrabbit42 | Bunny | Run | | 183 | | Laser Hare Removal | |  | Bunny Bits | lacota | Run | Run | | 184 | | Lava | |  | Bunny Bits | StephenK | Terrible Misfortune | Play Immediately! | | 185 | | Leaving On A Jet Plane | |  | Bunny Bits | battlehawk77 | Run | Run | | 186 | | Lucky Rabbit's Foot | |  | Bunny Bits | Watergazer | Run | Run | | 187 | | Lucky Seven | |  | Bunny Bits | samu | Very Special | Very Special | | 188 | | Married Bunnies | |  | Bunny Bits | TheDavii | Run | Run | | 189 | | Max's Straitjacket | |  | Bunny Bits | omfgitsvico | Run | Run | | 190 | | Measles | Weapon Level 12 |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Weapon | Run | | 191 | | The “Mini” lith | |  | Bunny Bits | johnlivingston | Run | Run | | 192 | | Monster Truck Rally | |  | Bunny Bits | glasscrosses | Run | Run | | 193 | | Moons and Goochers | |  | Bunny Bits | FiFisDead | Run | Run | | 194 | | Mummy Bunny | |  | Bunny Bits | Watergazer | Run | Run | | 195 | | Myxomatosis | Weapon Level 15 |  | Bunny Bits | mjibber | Roaming Red Run | Run | | 196 | | Nachos | Weapon Level 10 |  | Bunny Bits | johnlivingston | Weapon | Run | | 197 | | The Nanolith | |  | | samu | Special | Special | | 198 | | Necrobunnicon | |  | Bunny Bits | maelic001 | Special | Special | | 199 | | No Peeking | |  | Bunny Bits | samu | Run | Run | | 200 | | No Sir, I Don't Like It | |  | Bunny Bits | fifisDead | Very Special | Very Special |
|
|
|
|
Post by fifisdead on Sept 5, 2008 0:10:16 GMT -5
ok, I put the thread location under each picture link... Which I guess will all have to change if i have to remove the MC logo from them...  |
|
|
|
Post by fifisdead on Sept 5, 2008 1:23:57 GMT -5
|
|
|
|
Post by TheDavii on Sept 5, 2008 6:38:15 GMT -5
As you probably noticed, I ran out of space in the 60K characters available in a message, when trying more than 140 cards per message (143 broke it), so I had to split them across three messages. When we're done, I hope we can get the moderators to allow me to make a "sticky" topic with three threads for all of the 275 cards (!!) we have. The one posting for Tyberius (with 8 cards) violates the Ground Rule for one card per picture. If someone (like Tyberius) wants to split them into individual files, I'll be happy to post them in the list. Here are the statistics so far: Count of distinct cards, by artist[/right][/td][/tr] [tr][td]mjibber[/td][td] 57 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]FIFisDead[/td][td] 43 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]TheDavii[/td][td] 35 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]omfgitsvico[/td][td] 29 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]samu[/td][td] 24 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Watergazer[/td][td] 13 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]StephenK[/td][td] 9 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]lacota[/td][td] 8 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]dedrabbit42[/td][td] 6 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Jeffro[/td][td] 6 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]a6cavey[/td][td] 5 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]battlehawk77[/td][td] 5 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]glasscrosses[/td][td] 4 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Trebor1782[/td][td] 4 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]squidtaco[/td][td] 3 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Tyberius[/td][td] 3 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]bunnyfromthefuture[/td][td] 2 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]derek[/td][td] 2 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Jason Pease[/td][td] 2 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Johnlivingston[/td][td] 2 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Toddles[/td][td] 2 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]baylorgirl[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Darth Vadehare[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]HaresonFord[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Jescor[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]kurt[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]maelic001[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]moustachoied[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [/table] Count of cards, by type[/right][/td][/tr] [tr][td]Run[/td][td] 166 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Special[/td][td] 45 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Very Special[/td][td] 43 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Play Immediately![/td][td] 14 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Starter Card[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Carrot Supply[/td][td] 0 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Dolla[/td][td] 0 [/td][/tr] [tr][td] [/td][td] 2 [/td][/tr] [/table] Count of cards, by kind[/right][/td][/tr] [tr][td]Run[/td][td] 126 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Special[/td][td] 44 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Very Special[/td][td] 42 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Bunny[/td][td] 25 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Roaming Red Run[/td][td] 8 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Weapon[/td][td] 7 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Terrible Misfortune[/td][td] 8 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Incredible Fortune[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Incredible Misfortune[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Omega[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Psi[/td][td] 1 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Carrot[/td][td] 0 [/td][/tr] [tr][td]Dolla[/td][td] 0 [/td][/tr] [tr][td] [/td][td] 7 [/td][/tr] [/table] |
|
